One year later: Stimulus bill failed to create jobs

By Tom Cole, Oklahoma Representative
Posted Feb 17, 2010 @ 03:56 PM
Last update Feb 18, 2010 @ 11:57 AM
Print Comment

Almost exactly a year after seeing 787 billion of their tax dollars evaporate courtesy of a so­called “stimulus bill,” Americans are justifiably running out of patience and asking “Where are the jobs?” President Obama and congressional Democrats rushed the stimulus bill through Congress last Febru­ary amid dire predictions that failure to pass the bill would result in double-digit unemployment, while pas­sage would keep the jobless rate below 8 percent.


In the months after President Obama signed the stimulus bill into law, the unemployment rate topped 10 percent and remains close to that today. Nation­wide, 3.3 million jobs have been lost. Oklahoma saw its unemployment rate jump from 4.2 percent to 7.1 percent in a year’s time. Our state’s jobless rate has ticked back down slightly to 6.6 percent, but that’s little comfort to those who are still out of work.


I voted against the stimulus bill because I believed it was a pork­laden giveaway to liberal special in­terest groups that would serve only to grow the government and add to the deficit while doing too little to create jobs and invest in our infra­structure. One year later, it’s clear that the stimulus bill has failed even more spectacu­larly than I had feared.


Remarkably, the Obama administration’s response to this failed economic experiment is more of the same. Rather than embracing policies that would reduce the size of government and provide tax incentives for small businesses to create jobs, they remain sidetracked by other objectives, like a record-breaking spending plan and a government takeover of our health care system. Along with the misguided cap-and-trade bill, these policies actually discourage employers from hiring by creating uncertainty in the markets and guaranteeing punishing tax hikes for businesses and manufactur­ers. It’s no wonder businesses are hesitant to make new hires when they know the liberals who control Washington, D.C., are poised to pass bill after bill that will dramatically raise costs and impose new regula­tions.


There is one indication that President Obama and his allies learned something over the past year. While they prepare to shove another multi-billion dollar spending bill through Congress, they no longer refer to it as a “stimulus” bill; now they call it a “jobs” bill. But make no mistake: They may have changed the name, but the substance of the legislation remains the same – more spending, more government and more debt. By contrast, conservatives have proposed an economic re­covery plan that promotes job creation through a va­riety of fiscally responsible policies, including targeted tax cuts for businesses.

Almost exactly a year after seeing 787 billion of their tax dollars evaporate courtesy of a so­called “stimulus bill,” Americans are justifiably running out of patience and asking “Where are the jobs?” President Obama and congressional Democrats rushed the stimulus bill through Congress last Febru­ary amid dire predictions that failure to pass the bill would result in double-digit unemployment, while pas­sage would keep the jobless rate below 8 percent.


In the months after President Obama signed the stimulus bill into law, the unemployment rate topped 10 percent and remains close to that today. Nation­wide, 3.3 million jobs have been lost. Oklahoma saw its unemployment rate jump from 4.2 percent to 7.1 percent in a year’s time. Our state’s jobless rate has ticked back down slightly to 6.6 percent, but that’s little comfort to those who are still out of work.


I voted against the stimulus bill because I believed it was a pork­laden giveaway to liberal special in­terest groups that would serve only to grow the government and add to the deficit while doing too little to create jobs and invest in our infra­structure. One year later, it’s clear that the stimulus bill has failed even more spectacu­larly than I had feared.


Remarkably, the Obama administration’s response to this failed economic experiment is more of the same. Rather than embracing policies that would reduce the size of government and provide tax incentives for small businesses to create jobs, they remain sidetracked by other objectives, like a record-breaking spending plan and a government takeover of our health care system. Along with the misguided cap-and-trade bill, these policies actually discourage employers from hiring by creating uncertainty in the markets and guaranteeing punishing tax hikes for businesses and manufactur­ers. It’s no wonder businesses are hesitant to make new hires when they know the liberals who control Washington, D.C., are poised to pass bill after bill that will dramatically raise costs and impose new regula­tions.


There is one indication that President Obama and his allies learned something over the past year. While they prepare to shove another multi-billion dollar spending bill through Congress, they no longer refer to it as a “stimulus” bill; now they call it a “jobs” bill. But make no mistake: They may have changed the name, but the substance of the legislation remains the same – more spending, more government and more debt. By contrast, conservatives have proposed an economic re­covery plan that promotes job creation through a va­riety of fiscally responsible policies, including targeted tax cuts for businesses.


The president has been talking a lot lately about bipartisanship. Unfortunately, his idea of bipartisan cooperation begins and ends with his proposal to in­vite Republicans to a televised summit…about Demo­crat- authored health care legislation. Not only does this symbolic gesture fail to give fair consideration to Republican proposals, it ignores the more pressing issues of job creation, spending restraint and deficit reduction. The American people are most certainly focused on these issues even if the Obama adminis­tration is not. By truly considering Republican plans, the president can show both bipartisanship and seri­ousness about making the tough choices necessary for economic recovery. It is my hope he will do so in the months ahead.

Loading commenting interface...

Site Services
Contact Us
Place an Ad
E-Ardmoreite
Manage Account
Archives
Market Place
Classifieds
Find Ardmore jobs
Coupons
RadarFrog
Today's Ads
Site Links
Special Sections
H.S. Football
Golf
Anniversaries
Holiday
NIE